Casey Toof was born and raised in St. Albans City. He attended St. Albans City Elementary School, BFA, and Castleton University in Castleton, VT where he earned a degree in History and Education. Casey currently owns his own consulting firm Toof Consulting where he specializes in social media and email marketing.

Casey has coached at BFA from 2011-2016, helping his brother with the varsity boys basketball program. Before that Casey coached many other youth programs around Franklin County. Casey is also a member of the Sons of the American Legion and he is a member of the St. Albans Town Planning Commission.

Casey resides on Clyde Allen Drive in St. Albans Town with his two children Callan and Lukas, and their lab Natty.