Casey Toof was born and raised in St. Albans City. He attended St. Albans City Elementary School, BFA, and Castleton University in Castleton, VT where he earned a degree in History and Education. Casey currently owns his own consulting firm Toof Consulting where he specializes in social media and email marketing.

Casey has coached at BFA from 2011-2016, helping his brother with the varsity boys basketball program. Before that Casey coached many other youth programs around Franklin County. Casey is also a member of the Sons of the American Legion and he is a member of the St. Albans Town Planning Commission.

In July of 2014, Casey married the love of his life Ashley. Ashley works as a Public Works Engineer for the City of Burlington Public Works Department. They reside on Clyde Allen Drive in St. Albans Town with their two children Callan and Lukas, and their two labs Natty and Bella.